Before the pineapple
Smith & Cross instead of both rums, Antica instead of Cinzano, a third each: no pineapple, far more bitter, and as rich as Rum Negronis get. The Kingston before Chicago got hold of it.
The Rum Negroni that came out of a tiki bar.
Shelby Allison and Paul McGee, Lost Lake, ChicagoGive it a few minutes in the freezer, or fill it with ice while you mix.
Into a mixing glass, in this order.
Fill the mixing glass with ice and stir until the outside feels cold to hold.
Proper dilution means enough water from melting ice to bring everything together without making the drink taste washed out. Stir with ice and taste as you go: the drink should be cold, with plenty of flavour. Timing varies with your ice.
Tip out any chilling ice, add one large fresh cube and strain the drink over it. The ice you stirred with stays behind.
Squeeze the orange peel over the drink so the oil lands on top, then drop it in.
Measure the Campari and Cinzano as written. Their smaller measures are what let the pineapple through; pour them freely and the bitter takes the room back.
Before the pineapple
Smith & Cross instead of both rums, Antica instead of Cinzano, a third each: no pineapple, far more bitter, and as rich as Rum Negronis get. The Kingston before Chicago got hold of it.
At Lost Lake in Chicago, Shelby Allison and Paul McGee gave the Kingston pineapple. Two rums go in where the gin was: Appleton Signature, and Stiggins’ Fancy, a rum infused with pineapple. The Campari and Cinzano Rosso take slightly smaller measures to make room for both. If the Stiggins’ on your shelf says Plantation on the label, that’s the brand’s old name; it became Planteray in 2024.